Image credit: Photo by Morio, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0. (credit links at the end of the content)
We continue bringing you fascinating what-if stories from Formula 1’s past. One of the most interesting involves German driver Nico Hülkenberg. Mercedes tried to sign him on several occasions but never managed to secure his services as a full-time driver. What went wrong, and How Close Was Nico Hülkenberg to Joining Mercedes?
When I look back at his career and statistics, I never thought his numbers would look this way. He secured one pole position during his career but was never able to win a Formula 1 race. What if he had joined Mercedes? Would he have had a chance to become world champion? It’s a million-dollar question, but Nico always looked capable of fighting at the front, especially after taking pole position at the Brazilian GP while driving for Williams. Unfortunately, luck was never really on his side.
How Close Was Nico Hülkenberg to Joining Mercedes?
Nico Hülkenberg was on Mercedes’ radar on more than one occasion. The team showed interest in signing him several times throughout his career. His name also emerged following Nico Rosberg’s retirement in 2016, while another opportunity came in 2021 when he became part of Mercedes’ reserve driver arrangements.
2013: Hülkenberg Was Mercedes’ Second Choice Behind Hamilton
The first serious opportunity came in 2012, when Michael Schumacher decided to retire from Formula 1 for the second time, after leaving Ferrari at the end of 2006.
At the same time, Lewis Hamilton was considering his future at McLaren. Mercedes identified the 2008 world champion as a potential replacement and partner for Nico Rosberg in 2013, but negotiations were not straightforward, so Mercedes looked for alternatives.
One of them was Nico Hülkenberg, who had impressed during his early F1 career. After making his debut with Williams in 2010 and taking pole position at the Brazilian GP in his rookie year, he showed plenty of potential. He then spent a year as a reserve driver for Force India before securing a full-time racing seat in 2012.
That race at the Brazilian GP helped Nico strengthen his reputation. He even led the race before an incident with Hamilton ended his chances of fighting for victory.
Ross Brawn later reportedly confirmed that Hülkenberg was Mercedes’ second choice behind Hamilton. Had the British driver decided to remain at McLaren, Hülkenberg would have had a strong chance of partnering Nico Rosberg for 2013. But Hamilton accepted Mercedes’ offer, leaving no place for Hülkenberg, who then signed with Sauber for the 2013 season.
Looking back, that was the closest he came to securing a regular Mercedes seat.
2017: Another Opportunity After Rosberg’s Shock Retirement
Hülkenberg’s name resurfaced in 2016, following one of the biggest surprises in modern F1 history. Just days after winning his first world title, Nico Rosberg announced his retirement, leaving Mercedes with an unexpected vacancy and another opportunity for a driver to secure the seat.
Toto Wolff and Mercedes suddenly needed a replacement. Hülkenberg was among the drivers considered, and Wolff reportedly contacted Renault to explore the possibility of signing him.
But the situation was complicated. Hülkenberg had already committed himself to Renault, having signed a deal to join the French team for 2017.
Renault was unwilling to release its newly signed driver, while Hülkenberg also made it clear that he intended to honour his agreement.
Mercedes looked at other possibilities. The team reportedly considered drivers like Pascal Wehrlein and even Daniel Ricciardo, but eventually decided to go for Valtteri Bottas, who was driving for Williams at the time.
So, for Hülkenberg, another potentially career-changing opportunity had disappeared.
2021: Hülkenberg Finally Joined Mercedes, But Not as a Race Driver
Although the previous opportunities never resulted in a full-time Mercedes seat, Hulk eventually became part of the team’s reserve driver arrangements in 2021. Mercedes already had Vandoorne and de Vries as reserve drivers, but their Formula E commitments sometimes created scheduling conflicts.
Hülkenberg provided an additional option. He had already shown his value as a replacement driver during his appearances for Racing Point in 2020, when he stepped in for Pérez and Stroll.
For 2021, he continued his reserve role with Aston Martin while also being available to Mercedes at selected events when its regular reserve drivers were unavailable. He never had to replace either Hamilton or Bottas, meaning he didn’t get the opportunity to make his Mercedes race debut.
What If Hülkenberg Had Joined Mercedes?
His career could have looked very different, as we mentioned at the beginning of our article, if he had joined the Mercedes F1 team.
As we said, things could have been different. Nico Hülkenberg remains on the list of drivers with just one pole position since the 1980s, but would that statistic still look the same if he had joined Mercedes? The answer is NO. From 2014 to 2020, Mercedes was the most dominant team on the grid, and we saw what Bottas and Rosberg achieved during those years by taking numerous pole positions and victories. So, for Hulk, would it have been the same?
Another interesting statistic is that he belongs to the list of drivers with the most laps led without ever winning a race in F1. So, there is another question: would that have remained the same? Again, the answer is no. Hulk would likely have won races with Mercedes during those years, but that’s why we said that luck was never on his side.
However, looking back, Hamilton joined the team and went on to win multiple world titles with Mercedes.
Of course, it is impossible to know whether Hülkenberg would have achieved the same success or at least won a world title, but the German driver would certainly have had opportunities to fight for victories and secure many more pole positions in F1.
So, what remains clear is that Hulk wasn’t simply a name mentioned in passing. Mercedes knew what he was capable of and seriously considered him for the team. But that day never came, neither for Hülkenberg nor for Mercedes, and that partnership never happened!
Featured Image Credits: Photo by Morio, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.
